| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
In this investigation, we examined the relationship among three thrombin inhibitors, antithrombin III (ATIII), heparin cofactor II (HCII), and -2-macroglobulin ( 2M), and several clinical tests of heparins effect in pediatric patients with congenital heart disease undergoing cardiopulmonary bypass. One hundred eighteen children were stratified into six age groups: <1 mo, 13 mo, 36 mo, 612 mo, 1224 mo, and >10 yr. Baseline ATIII, HCII, and 2M values were measured. Baseline celite- and kaolin-activated clotting times (ACT) were also measured and repeated 3 min after a standard heparin dose of 400 U/kg. Differences in ACT values before and after heparin administration and a heparin doseresponse relationship were calculated for each patient. Kaolin-activated ACT tests showed less variation after heparin administration than celite-activated tests. In contrast to what has been demonstrated in adults, ATIII showed no positive correlation with the clinical tests of heparins effect nor did the other thrombin inhibitors. Additionally, patients <1 mo old had unexpectedly low levels of 2M accompanying their expected low levels of ATIII and HCII. Our findings raise concerns about the ability of heparin to adequately anticoagulate these neonates during cardiopulmonary bypass and, consequently, challenge the accuracy of ACT prolongation to truly reflect the extent of their anticoagulation.
The coagulation system of infants begins its development during gestation and continues to evolve into the adult state in the postnatal period. There are distinct differences between the coagulation system of infants during the first 6 mo of life and that of adults, including quantitative and qualitative differences in most procoagulants and inhibitors, differences in the ability to generate thrombin, and differences in the ability to inhibit thrombin once it is formed (1). These differences are often further exaggerated in infants with altered physiologies, including those with congenital heart disease (CHD). The differences in thrombin generation and inhibition are particularly relevant for pediatric patients undergoing cardiac surgery. The use of cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) requires heparin administration to prevent clot formation within the extracorporeal circuit, and normal antithrombin III (ATIII) concentrations are required to effectively catalyze this antithrombotic action of heparin. Several studies in adult cardiac surgical patients confirm the correlation between the level of ATIII activity and the degree of the anticoagulant response to heparin administration before the institution of CPB (2,3). Indeed, in adult patients with subnormal ATIII activity, supplementation with ATIII concentrate results in the enhancement of heparins effect (4).
In neonates and infants, ATIII levels do not reach adult values until 36 mo of age (1,5,6). There is concern therefore regarding the ability to adequately anticoagulate ATIII-deficient pediatric patients who require CPB to correct a congenital heart defect. In fact, recent evidence suggests that the physiologically low ATIII levels in children may reduce the efficacy of heparin in neutralizing thrombin generation during CPB (7,8). Although ATIII is the main protease inhibitor of thrombin in adult plasma, other thrombin inhibitors, heparin-cofactor II (HCII) and
After obtaining IRB approval and written, informed parental consent, 118 children scheduled for elective cardiac surgical procedures requiring the use of CPB were enrolled in this prospective, observational study. Patients receiving preoperative anticoagulant therapy were excluded. Patients were stratified into six age groups: <1 mo, 13 mo, 36 mo, 612 mo, 1224 mo, and >10 yr. Blood samples were drawn from an indwelling arterial line catheter after aspirating 5 mL of blood to insure that no heparin from the flush solutions was present in the collection sample. Baseline celite- and kaolin-activated clotting times (ACTs) (Hemochron Response, International Technidyne Corporation, Edison, NJ) were measured. Blood was also obtained to measure baseline ATIII (Coamatic Antithrombin, DiaPharma Group, West Chester, OH), HCII (Actichrome® Heparin Cofactor II, American Diagnostica, Greenwich, CT) and 2M (BN* II System, Dade Behring, Deerfield, IL) levels. Blood samples were placed into the appropriate prechilled tubes and centrifuged for 20 min. The resultant plasma was pipetted into cryovials (Sybron, Rochester, NY) for storage at 70°C until assayed within batches. A standard dose of porcine heparin, 400 U/kg, was administered in preparation for CPB. Three minutes after heparin administration, celite- and kaolin-ACTs were repeated. To measure heparins effectiveness, changes in the celite- and kaolin-ACT values resulting from heparin administration and a heparin doseresponse relationship (HDRR), as described by Lemmer and Despotis (4), were calculated for each patient. The HDRR was determined by dividing the change in ACT values before and after heparin administration by an estimate of the whole-blood heparin concentration. The HDRR-celite (HDRR-c) and the HDRR-kaolin (HDRR-k) were calculated using the changes in celite- and kaolin-ACT, respectively. As per Lemmer and Despotis (4), estimates of the whole-blood heparin concentration were obtained by dividing the total heparin dose in units by the patients blood volume in milliliters. Calculations of circulating blood volume were based upon the following averages: 85 mL/kg for patients <1 mo, 80 mL/kg for patients 112 mo, 75 mL/kg for patients 1224 mo, and 70 mL/kg for the patients >10 yr (1012). For each age group, using the SAS GLM procedure, a means model was used to determine estimates of the means and standard deviations of baseline platelet counts, fibrinogen, and thrombin inhibitor levels and the results of the tests of heparin effect. The means model was then used to look for pairwise differences between the means of each variable among the different age groups. A Bonferroni adjustment was used for the 15 pairwise age comparisons making a P value <0.003 significant. Testing for overall linear association between age and thrombin inhibitor levels was conducted by Pearson correlation analyses. Likewise, Pearson correlation analyses were performed within each age group to determine linear association between thrombin inhibitor levels and heparin responses. Multivariable regression analyses were performed for HDRR-c and HDRR-k.
A total of 118 patients presenting for elective cardiac surgery requiring CPB were enrolled in this study. Fifty-two percent of patients were female, and 48% were male. Patients were stratified into six age groups: <1 mo (n = 20), 13 mo (n = 19), 36 mo (n = 20), 612 mo (n = 19), 1224 mo (n = 20), and >10 yr (n = 20). The cardiac defects in the children of each age group are delineated in Table 1. Distribution of preoperative platelet counts and fibrinogen levels for each age group are shown in Table 2.
The mean differences in celite- and kaolin-ACT values before and after heparin administration were compared among the age groups, as were the mean differences in the calculated HDRR-c and HDRR-k values (Table 3). When examining the mean change in celite-ACT, there were statistical differences between <1-mo-old and 13-mo-old patients as well as between 13-mo-old and 612-mo-old patients. With respect to the mean change in the kaolin-ACT, no statistical differences were noted among the different age groups. Comparisons of the mean HDRR-c among the different age groups showed statistical differences between patients <1 mo and patients in the 13 mo, 1224 mo, and >10 yr age groups (Fig. 1A). There were no statistical differences among the mean HDRR-k values in the different age groups (Fig. 1B).
In children <24 mo of age, we found significant correlations between age and thrombin inhibitor levels (P
To compare pediatric and representative adult values, we calculated the amount of each thrombin inhibitor present in the different age groups as a percentage of that in the >10 yr group (Table 4). In neonates, mean ATIII levels were 78.9%, mean HCII levels were 73.9%, and mean
We sought potential correlations between the thrombin inhibitors and the different heparin responses in each age group. In patients <1 mo, a significant negative correlation was found between
Multivariable stepwise regression analysis revealed that significant factors in predicting HDRR-c include age, preoperative platelet count, and HCII levels (HDRR-c = 326 0.32 * age 60 * HCII 0.19 * platelet; P < 0.0001). Age, preoperative platelet count and preoperative fibrinogen levels were significant in predicting HDRR-k (HDRR-k = 388 0.27 * age 0.40 * fibrinogen 0.20 * platelet; P < 0.0001).
The purpose of this study was three-fold: to investigate the changes in tests of heparins effect after its administration before the institution of CPB to children of various age groups, to compare the levels of three thrombin inhibitors among these age groups, and to analyze the relationships between each thrombin inhibitor and the tests of heparins effect in each age group. After heparin administration, responses to kaolin-activated coagulation tests showed less variation among the different age groups than the responses seen with celite activation. Measured ATIII, HCII and 2M levels correlated with age, and were lowest in the neonatal group in comparison with the older children. Furthermore, 2M levels were found to be lower in our neonates with CHD than levels reported in the literature for otherwise healthy neonates (1,13). No significant positive correlations were found between any of the thrombin inhibitors and the measured heparin responses in any age group. In patients <1 mo old, however, 2M showed a consistent inverse correlation with all of the tests of heparins effect.
The hemostatic system of a newborn is dynamic and well-balanced, yet it is distinctly different from that of an adult. Previous studies have shown that levels of certain thrombin inhibitors, namely ATIII and HCII, are lower at birth than those in adults, whereas levels of other inhibitors such as
Although our results confirm low levels of ATIII in neonates, we found much lower levels of This concern however seems to be refuted by the measures of heparins effect that we observed in our neonates. We found a statistically significant prolongation of celite-ACTs and steeper HDRR-c slopes in the neonatal group, even with low levels of thrombin inhibitors. Kaolin-ACTs and HDRR-k slopes, though not significantly different, also trended higher in the neonatal group, suggesting that these neonates are actually more anticoagulated by heparin. This observation may be explained either by a decreased ability of neonates to generate thrombin or by the fact that the ACT is a poor indicator of heparin-induced thrombin inhibition in neonates during cardiac surgery. Although healthy neonates have decreased levels of prothrombin and other procoagulants, which limit their ability to generate thrombin, neonates presenting for cardiac surgery are capable of producing large amounts of thrombin in the perioperative period (8,19). Unlike healthy neonates, they undergo preoperative events, such as the placement of indwelling umbilical or central lines and interventional manipulations in the cardiac catheterization laboratory, that perhaps trigger hemostatic activation. Therefore, it is difficult to presume that the prolonged ACTs seen in neonates are due to depressed thrombin-generating activity. The limitations of the ACT as an indicator of heparins effect may provide a more likely explanation. Because the ACT does not detect thrombin as a specific end-point, and is subject to the effect of other variables, it may not accurately reflect heparin-induced anticoagulation, especially during neonatal cardiac surgery. First, ACT values do not necessarily correlate with plasma heparin levels during CPB. Interpretation of the celite-ACT response to high-dose heparin is complicated by the loss of a linear doseresponse curve at ACT values more that 600 s (20). Even in the linear portion of the doseresponse curve, there is considerable variation in single-measurement ACT responses to heparin administration in adult cardiac surgical patients (21). Second, confounding variables, such as hypothermia and hemodilution, that are particularly prevalent in the pediatric realm further hinder the ability of the ACT to provide accurate information regarding plasma heparin levels (20). Third, the immature coagulation systems found in neonatal patients, specifically a paucity of contact activation factors (factors XII and XI, prekallikrein, and high-molecular-weight kininogen), complicates the interpretation of prolonged ACT values (22). Lastly, prostaglandin E1, a frequently used pharmacologic adjunct during the neonatal period, and a notable inhibitor of platelet aggregation, again may enhance ACT prolongations without accurately reflecting plasma heparin activity (23). These points suggest that the ACT may be a poor determinant of adequate thrombin inhibition in neonates during cardiac surgery, thus raising concerns about monitoring anticoagulation for neonates during often-prolonged periods of CPB using the ACT test as the sole measure of heparins effect. Monitoring of heparin levels may provide a more accurate guide for the administration of heparin during neonatal CPB, and deserves further study.
Some of our data may explain previous thromboelastogram findings of increased coagulability in young infants noted by other authors (24,25). Depending on the concentration of ATIII in the surrounding plasma, In our study, the change in celite-ACT values in response to heparin administration prior to CPB shows significant variability among the different age groups. The HDRR-c, being a calculated number using the change in celite-ACT, also shows significant variability among the age groups. Conversely, the change in kaolin-ACT and, consequently, the HDRR-k, show a more consistent response among the age groupings. Changes in kaolin-ACT values in response to high-dose heparin administration for CPB in adult cardiac surgical patients have also been shown to demonstrate greater consistency than celite-mediated responses (2729). Our data suggest that the kaolin-ACT may be more appropriate than the celite-ACT in measuring heparins effect for CPB in pediatric patients.
Cardiac surgery involving CPB is a powerful activator of the hemostatic system. Effective anticoagulation with unfractionated heparin is used to prevent not only grossly visible clot formation but also microemboli. In adult cardiac surgical patients, heparins anticoagulant effects are intimately dependent on ATIII activity. Consequently, low levels of ATIII plasma activity impair heparins ability to provide adequate anticoagulation, as demonstrated by both a decreased HDRR and a decreased ability to prevent excessive thrombin generation (2,30). In this pediatric study, however, we found no correlation between ATIII levels and the change in ACT with heparin administration, or between ATIII levels and the HDRR. None of the thrombin inhibitors showed a positive correlation with the clinical measures of heparins effect. Conversely, In summary, our investigation demonstrates that kaolin-ACTs of heparins effect in children with CHD show less variable results than coagulation tests activated by celite. Our data also reveal that neonates with CHD are distinct from healthy neonates and from older pediatric patients with CHD, in that neonates with CHD may be deficient in all three of the major thrombin inhibitors. Although deficiencies in thrombin inhibitor levels may help explain the recent findings of excess thrombin formation in neonates presenting for cardiac surgery (8), they oppose this studys other finding of increased heparin effect as measured by the ACT in these same neonates. This inconsistency makes us question the accuracy of the ACT test in assessing heparin-induced anticoagulation for CPB in neonates. Further research is needed to help explain these discrepancies.
Accepted for publication July 27, 2006.
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|