| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
BACKGROUND: The infusion of dextrose in patients receiving epidural and light general anesthesia or general anesthesia alone failed to achieve a positive protein balance. We sought to verify the hypothesis that nutritional supplementation with IV amino acids induced a greater protein balance in patients receiving epidural blockade compared with those receiving general anesthesia. METHODS: Sixteen patients were randomly assigned to receive either general anesthesia with desflurane (control group) or general anesthesia combined with epidural analgesia (EDA group). A primed constant infusion of stable isotope tracers l-[1-13C]leucine and [6,6-2H2]glucose was started after a 32-h fast before surgery, (3 h of fasted state), and continued for 3 h during surgery during which amino acids were infused IV (fed state). RESULTS: Compared with the fasted state, the endogenous rate of appearance of leucine decreased to a similar extent in both groups, and protein synthesis increased, with no difference between the two groups. Leucine oxidation did not change in either group. After amino acids infusion, endogenous glucose production remained unchanged and glucose clearance decreased in both groups. Blood glucose, plasma cortisol, serum insulin, and glucagon concentrations increased to the same extent in both groups. CONCLUSIONS: Epidural anesthesia provided no additional benefit beyond the anabolism obtained with amino acids.
Gluconeogenic amino acids released during muscle breakdown become the major source of precursors for de novo glucose synthesis (1). It has been hypothesized that any perioperative anesthetic or pharmacologic intervention aimed at inhibiting gluconeogenesis would cause a decrease in protein breakdown, thus leading to a better preservation of whole-body protein economy. In contrast, if catabolism is intense and untreated, postoperative convalescence can be protracted with increased morbidity as a result of perioperative erosion of lean body mass, immunosuppression, delayed wound healing, decreased muscle strength, and fatigue (13). Two previous studies assessed the impact of intraoperative epidural blockade supplemented by general anesthesia on endogenous glucose production (EGP), an indicator of gluconeogenesis, and whole-body protein breakdown and protein balance. In the first study (4), the intraoperative decrease in EGP was more pronounced in patients receiving epidural and light general anesthesia than in those receiving general anesthesia alone. However, in both groups, protein breakdown decreased to the same extent, and net protein balance, measured as protein synthesis minus protein breakdown, was negative, implying that the type of anesthesia did not affect protein metabolism. In a subsequent investigation (5), dextrose was infused in the same groups of patients receiving the same anesthesia protocol as above, with the intent to decrease EGP to a greater extent and to achieve a positive protein balance. It was also hypothesized that the benefits on protein metabolism would have been more pronounced in the epidural group as a result of its greater ability to reduce EGP. However, even if epidural anesthesia caused a major decrease in EGP, net protein balance remained negative (5). Furthermore, the decrease in protein breakdown was smaller (18%) than when dextrose was not infused (23%), and blood glucose levels increased up to 10 mmol/L in both epidural and general anesthesia groups (5). The lack of anticatabolic action of exogenous glucose, associated with hyperglycemia, raised doubts about the value of infusing dextrose during surgery. Hyperglycemia has been associated with several disadvantageous clinical effects (610). Studies in surgical patients have demonstrated that infusion of amino acids spares protein and induces an anabolic state because it directly stimulates whole-body and muscle protein synthesis, and indirectly attenuates protein breakdown (11). With the understanding of the anabolic properties of infusing amino acids and the greater capacity of epidural blockade in decreasing EGP, this study sought 1) to test the hypothesis that supplementation of amino acids during surgery induces a greater positive protein balance in patients receiving an intraoperative epidural blockade compared with those receiving general anesthesia alone, and 2) to understand the interaction between protein and glucose metabolism during amino acids infusion. To quantify the dynamic changes in protein and glucose metabolism, whole-body protein breakdown, amino acid oxidation, protein synthesis, and EGP and glucose clearance were determined by an isotope dilution technique using stable isotopes l-[1-13C]leucine and [6,6-2H2]glucose.
Patients The study (GEN no. 04-014) was approved by the ethics committee of the Montreal General Hospital, and informed consent was obtained from 16 patients undergoing elective colorectal surgery. No patient was suffering from cardiac, hepatic, renal, or metabolic disorders or receiving any medication known to affect glucose metabolism. None of the participants had developed more than 10% weight loss over the preceding 3 mo or had a hemoglobin <100 g/L. Patients were randomly assigned to receive either general anesthesia with desflurane (control group) or the same general anesthesia combined with epidural analgesia (EDA group).
Anesthesia General anesthesia in the control group was maintained with desflurane at end-tidal concentrations as required to keep the heart rate within 20% of preoperative values. In the EDA group desflurane was administered at end-tidal concentrations of approximately 3 vol% to achieve tolerance of the endotracheal tube and to prevent awareness. The degree of muscle relaxation was monitored using train-of-four ratio, and supplemental doses of rocuronium were given to achieve complete surgical muscle relaxation throughout the surgery. IV fluid was given as NaCl 0.9% solution at a rate of 8 mL/kg/h. All patients were covered with a warming blanket during surgery to maintain normothermia. Hemodynamic monitoring was performed using a three-lead electrocardiogram monitor and radial artery catheterization for continuous arterial blood pressure measurement.
Amino Acids Infusion
Experimental Protocol All patients were studied on the day of surgery between 7:00 and 8:00 am after fasting for approximately 32 h. Only clear fluids were allowed until midnight the day preceding the operation because of bowel preparation as required for colorectal surgery. No premedication was given. A cannula was inserted in the superficial vein in the dorsum of the hand to provide access for the infusion of the isotopes. Under local anesthesia, a 22-gauge catheter was inserted in the artery of the opposite arm for sampling of arterial blood. Blood and expired air samples were collected before the isotope infusion to determine baseline isotope enrichments. Primed doses of 1 µmol/kg NaH13CO3, 4 µmol/kg l-[1-13C]leucine, and 22 µmol/kg [6,6-2H2]glucose were administered and followed immediately by a continuous infusion of 0.06 µmol/kg/min l-[1-13C]leucine and 0.22 µmol/kg/min [6,6-2H2]glucose. Four arterial blood and expired-air samples were collected at 150, 160, 170, and 180 min into the isotope infusion (fasted state), when the tracers were assumed to have reached an isotopic steady state. Thereafter, anesthesia was induced and surgery begun. At the same time, the infusion of amino acids was started and the rate of infusion of l-[1-13C]leucine was doubled to 0.12 µmol/kg/min. Four arterial blood and expired-air samples were taken at 330, 340, 350, and 360 min into the isotope infusion (fed state). Plasma samples for the analysis of blood glucose and plasma hormones (insulin, glucagon, cortisol) were drawn at 150 and 330 min of isotopes infusion. A graphic illustration of the study protocol is presented in Figure 1.
Analytical Methods and Calculations
Sample Size and Statistical Analysis
Patient Characteristics There were no differences between the two groups regarding age, weight, sex, and the ASA classification (Table 1). Type of surgery, duration of surgery, estimated blood loss, and the amount of crystalloid fluids administered were comparable in both groups.
Hemodynamics and Other Variables
Leucine Kinetics
Glucose Kinetics
Hormones
The results of this study indicate that patients receiving amino acids infusion during surgery maintained a positive protein balance, with no difference between epidural and general anesthesia. The same lack of influence on body protein economy by the type of anesthesia (general alone versus general plus epidural) has been found in previous intraoperative studies conducted either in a fasting state (4) or during a glucose infusion (5), and the net protein balance was negative in both states, lending support to the contention that during surgery the type of substrate infused is the only factor influencing protein metabolism. Studies conducted in the postoperative period have shown that the type of anesthesia influences protein metabolism. In fact, epidural blockade, compared with IV opioids, improved nitrogen balance (13), blunted the decrease in muscle fractional synthetic rate (14), attenuated the increase in whole-body protein breakdown and oxidation (15), and enhanced protein synthesis (12). These positive effects were observed only in association with parenteral nutrition or with an infusion of a mixture of amino acids and glucose. If only glucose was provided, the net protein balance became negative, and epidural analgesia was unable to modify protein synthesis and breakdown when compared with IV opioids with patient-controlled analgesia (2). One would conclude that intraoperative epidural blockade does not affect protein metabolism regardless of the type of nutritional support, while after surgery it exerts an anabolic effect only during nitrogenous nutritional supplementation. In an attempt to explain the present findings one would hypothesize that the lack of an enhanced anabolic effect by intraoperative epidural anesthesia might be the result of an attenuation of whole-body protein breakdown due to general anesthesia itself. A decrease in protein breakdown and synthesis has been shown to occur in patients undergoing colorectal surgery during inhaled desflurane and IV propofol anesthesia (16). Similarly, a decrease in all aspects of protein metabolism has been reported during enflurane anesthesia for total abdominal hysterectomy (17). In view of these findings, the inhibitory effect of anesthesia, observed in the present study, might have masked the positive effect on protein synthesis that one would otherwise have expected with epidural anesthesia. Previous results have suggested that whole-body and muscle protein synthesis is stimulated almost linearly within the normal physiological range of plasma amino acids, and that a two- to threefold increase in plasma concentrations of amino acids is required to saturate the system (18). In view of this, the rate of infusion of amino acids was selected to be 2.9 g/kg/day, with the intention to achieve a plasma amino acid concentration two- to threefold above basal value (19). Three hours of amino acids infusion is sufficient for maximal incorporation of amino acids into whole-body and tissue compartments. Beyond 3 h, muscle protein synthesis decreases back to basal values despite amino acid infusion continuing at the same rate (20). It is interesting to observe that, although the real quantity of amino acids administered was 0.36 g/kg/d and less than the daily recommended intake of 1.5 g/kg/d (21), a consistent anabolic effect was shown. This agrees with previous findings demonstrating that amino acids are more efficiently used for maintaining lean body mass when given in divided doses rather than with a continuous infusion (20). This anabolic effect could also be due to the increase in insulin levels determined by the infusion of amino acids. With regard to the present findings on glucose metabolism, the baseline values of EGP were not modified after the infusion of amino acids, and this was independent of the type of anesthesia used, while glucose clearance decreased to the same extent with both techniques. The fact that epidural anesthesia had the same effect as general anesthesia alone on EGP is in contrast with previous intraoperative studies using a similar protocol and conducted during either saline infusion or feeding with dextrose (4,5). In those studies, epidural anesthesia decreased EGP more than general anesthesia alone, probably due to the suppression of glucagon secretion exerted only by epidural anesthesia. In contrast, in the present study, serum glucagon increased to the same extent in both groups, and this is related to the infusion of amino acids that stimulated glucagon secretion (22,23). The small, nonsignificant decrease in EGP (8% on average) after the infusion of amino acids is in agreement with a previous finding in surgical patients undergoing major abdominal surgery in which a perioperative infusion of amino acids mixture at 2 g/kg/d (24) decreased endogenous glucose production by 8%, but failed to reach statistical significance. In volunteers, on the contrary, amino acids increased EGP. Tappy et al. (23), using a stable isotopes technique, showed an increase in EGP by 84% after an infusion of amino acids at a rate of 4.8 g/kg/d. Such an increase had been explained as a result of a direct effect of amino acids acting as substrate for the gluconeogenic pathway and indirectly by increased plasma glucagon concentration which stimulates gluconeogenesis (23). This contrasting effect of amino acids might be explained by considering that anesthesia by itself decreases EGP (4,16,25,26), and therefore, by inhibiting gluconeogenesis, anesthesia might have increased the available amino acids for synthetic pathways. Despite the lack of change in EGP in both groups, a significant increase in blood glucose to values around 8 mmol/L was observed, implying that glucose uptake was decreased as reflected by a decrease in glucose clearance. The decrease in glucose uptake can be due either to anesthesia or amino acids infusion or both. Other studies have reported a decreased glucose utilization in brains of anesthetized animals (27,28). This could affect whole-body glucose turnover, as the human central nervous system represents 50%80% of basal whole-body glucose disposal after an overnight fast (29). A decrease in muscular activity would be also an expected consequence of general anesthesia, and this could contribute to a significant decrease in glucose use because muscle uptake accounts for about 20% of basal glucose consumption in a postabsorptive state (30). Thus, the reduction in glucose clearance could be simply related to the decrease in energy requirements of some tissues as reflected by the decrease in whole-body oxygen consumption observed under anesthesia. Amino acids also could decrease peripheral glucose uptake. In volunteers, amino acids inhibited glucose transport/phosphorylation resulting in a decreased intracellular use of glucose (31). The present study had some limitations. First, there was an extremely long period of preoperative starvation, approximately 32 h, because of the preoperative bowel preparation. This cannot be said for other major operations in which the fasting state is limited to 1012 h, and therefore the present findings need to be interpreted with caution. Second, the baseline values for Ra leucine, leucine oxidation, and protein synthesis were statistically different between the groups, which occurred by pure coincidence. For this reason we compared the differences (fast and fed states) between groups. In conclusion, intraoperative infusion of amino acids induces a positive protein balance, independent of the anesthetic technique. In addition, amino acids supplementation did not influence gluconeogenesis, while whole-body glucose uptake decreased in both groups.
Dr. F. Donatelli was awarded a research fellowship by the McGill University Health Centre Foundation.
Accepted for publication August 14, 2006.
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|