| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
BACKGROUND: Although hemorrhagic shock decreases the minimum alveolar concentration (MAC) of inhaled anesthetics, it minimally alters the electroencephalographic (EEG) effect. Hemorrhagic shock also induces the release of endorphins, which are naturally occurring opioids. We tested whether the release of such opioids might explain the decrease in MAC. METHODS: Using the dew claw-clamp technique in 11 swine, we determined the isoflurane MAC before hemorrhage, after removal of 30% of the estimated blood volume (21 mL/kg of blood over 30 min), after fluid resuscitation using a volume of hydroxyethylstarch equivalent to the blood withdrawn, and after IV administration of 0.1 mg/kg of the µ-opioid antagonist naloxone. RESULTS: Hemorrhagic shock decreased the isoflurane MAC from 2.05% ± 0.28% to 1.50% ± 0.51% (P = 0.0007). Fluid resuscitation did not reverse MAC (1.59% ± 0.53%), but additional administration of naloxone restored it to control levels (1.96% ± 0.26%). The MAC values decreased depending on the severity of the shock, but the alterations in hemodynamic variables and metabolic changes accompanying fluid resuscitation or naloxone administration did not explain the changes in MAC. CONCLUSIONS: Consistent with previous reports, we found that hemorrhagic shock decreases MAC. In addition, we found that naloxone administration reversed the effect on MAC, and we propose that activation of the endogenous opioid system accounts for the decrease in MAC during hemorrhagic shock. Such an activation would not be expected to materially alter the EEG, an expectation consistent with our previous finding that hemorrhagic shock minimally alters the EEG.
Hemorrhagic shock increases the effect of several classes of IV anesthetics because of pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic changes (1–5), and such changes sometimes complicate the management of patients who have significant blood loss before or during surgery (6). We previously examined the influence of hemorrhagic shock on the electrolencephalogram (EEG) effect of isoflurane using a stepwise hemorrhagic model in swine, and concluded that hemorrhage, even at a level at which hemorrhagic shock progresses to a decompensated state, minimally alters the EEG effect of isoflurane (7,8). These results suggest that the use of an inhaled anesthetic, rather than an IV anesthetic, may allow for easier control of the hypnotic state in patients who have significant perioperative blood loss. However, the EEG only reflects the influence of hemorrhagic shock on hypnosis, not on immobility in response to noxious stimuli, which is also of importance for the definition of the potency of an inhaled anesthetic. The motor response to a noxious stimulus may be mediated primarily by subcortical structures, especially those in the spinal cord (9–11), and EEG parameters do not directly reflect the activity of these structures. In fact, it has been demonstrated that hemorrhagic shock decreases the minimum alveolar concentration (MAC) of inhaled anesthetics (12,13), in contrast to our previous finding that hemorrhagic shock minimally alters the EEG. We conducted the present study to clarify the influence of hemorrhagic shock on the MAC and to examine the associated mechanism, using a study protocol similar to that in our previous investigations into the influence of hemorrhagic shock on the hypnotic effect of isoflurane, because this allowed a comparison of differences between hypnotic and antinociceptive effects. First, MAC was assessed in a swine model in the hemorrhagic shock state to determine if MAC would decrease, as shown in previous reports (12,13). Subsequently, MAC was determined again after hydroxyethylstarch infusion to determine if an improvement in hemodynamics reversed the change in MAC. Finally, naloxone (a µ-opioid antagonist) was injected IV and MAC was assessed to determine if the induced changes could be reversed. Our rationale for testing the effect of naloxone was based on the demonstration by Molina that endogenous opioid activation during hemorrhagic shock produces analgesia in conscious and unrestrained rats, as measured using the tail-flick response to a noxious stimulus, and that this analgesia is not observed in hemorrhagic shock animals pretreated with naltrexone (a µ-opioid antagonist) (14). Therefore, we hypothesized that hemorrhagic shock would decrease the MAC of isoflurane, and fluid resuscitation would not reverse this change, but that additional administration of naloxone would restore MAC close to the baseline value.
Animal Preparation This study was approved by the Committee on Animal Research, Hamamatsu University School of Medicine, Hamamatsu, Japan. Eleven pigs (body-weight range: 23.1–40.7 kg, mean ± sd = 30.6 ± 5.7 kg) were used in the study. General anesthesia was induced by isoflurane inhalation (5%) in oxygen at 6 L/min using a standard animal mask. After tracheostomy, the lungs of the pigs were mechanically ventilated and anesthesia was maintained with a 2% end-tidal concentration of isoflurane in an oxygen–air mixture (oxygen:air = 3 L/min:3 L/min). The tidal volume was initially set to approximately 10 mL/kg and the ventilation rate 25 breaths per min. Expiratory gases were analyzed using a Capnomac Ultima (ULT-V-31-04, Datex-Ohmeda, Helsinki, Finland) throughout the study. The ventilator was adjusted to keep the end-tidal carbon dioxide between 35 mm Hg and 45 mm Hg during the preparation period, and this setting was maintained throughout the study. Lead II of an electrocardiogram was monitored using three cutaneous electrodes. A pulmonary artery catheter (5F, 4 lumen, Nihon Kohden, Tokyo, Japan) and a central venous catheter (16-gauge) were inserted via the right jugular vein, and another catheter (16-gauge) was placed in the right femoral artery. The blood temperature of the pigs was maintained between 39.0°C and 40.0°C.
Experimental Protocol
Determination of MAC
Statistical Analysis
Averaged metabolic and hemodynamic variables for each state are shown in Table 1. After removing 30% of the initial blood volume, base excess decreased and lactate increased, and both values significantly changed after fluid infusion because of temporary washout after peripheral hypoperfusion. Hematocrit increased after 30% bleeding and decreased after fluid infusion. Hemorrhage increased HR and decreased CVP and CO, but there was no significant change in MAP. Fluid infusion partially reversed the increase in HR and the decrease in CVP, and increased CO to more than the value observed under baseline conditions. This volume-expanding effect was attenuated after naloxone administration.
Hemorrhage decreased MAC to various extents in all except one animal. These values are shown for each condition in Figure 1. The mean MAC value after 30% bleeding differed significantly from those at baseline (P = 0.0007) and after 30% bleeding + fluid infusion + naloxone (P = 0.0043), and the mean MAC value after 30% bleeding + fluid infusion was also significantly different from those at baseline (P = 0.0043) and after 30% bleeding + fluid infusion + naloxone (P = 0.0235). MAC values decreased significantly after 30% bleeding and did not reverse after fluid infusion; however, administration of 0.1 mg/kg naloxone reversed the decrease in MAC, independently of the extent of the decrease.
The severity of hemorrhagic shock after 30% bleeding influenced the extent of the decrease in MAC. The percentage decrease in MAC (100 x [MAC at baseline – MAC after 30% bleeding]/MAC at baseline) significantly correlated with the percentage decrease in CO (100 x [CO at baseline – CO after 30% bleeding]/CO at baseline) (P < 0.0001, r2 = 0.824), and linear regression gave the following relationship: (percentage decrease in MAC) = 0.806 x (percentage decrease in CO). The percentage decrease in MAC also correlated significantly with the percentage increase in lactate (100 x [lactate after 30% bleeding – lactate at baseline]/lactate at baseline) (P = 0.0004, r2 = 0.736), and linear regression gave the following relationship: (percentage decrease in MAC) = 0.247 x (percentage increase in lactate). Although the MAC values decreased depending on the severity of the shock, alterations in hemodynamic variables and metabolic changes accompanying fluid resuscitation or naloxone administration did not explain the changes in MAC.
We investigated the influence of hemorrhagic shock, subsequent fluid resuscitation, and additional administration of naloxone on the MAC of isoflurane. Although there were some differences among animals, our results indicate that hemorrhage, to a level of 30% of the initial blood volume, decreases the MAC of isoflurane in most animals, consistent with previous reports (12,13). This is in contrast to results obtained in our previous studies in which hemorrhagic shock minimally altered the EEG effect of isoflurane, even in a decompensated state (7,8). The clinical implication of our results is that hemorrhagic shock increases the threshold for movement in response to noxious stimuli and that it is straightforward to obtain immobility using inhaled anesthetics; however, hypnotic potency does not alter in a comparable manner, suggesting that the concentration of an inhaled anesthetic should be decreased with care in patients with hemorrhagic shock during maintenance of hemodynamic stability. CO decreased by approximately 35% after 30% bleeding, but MAP did not decrease significantly. We observed compensatory increases of systemic vascular resistance and HR after 30% bleeding, as in our previous studies (7,16). Hence, hemorrhagic shock induced by 30% bleeding was considered to be a compensated state. However, because the degrees of hemodynamic and metabolic changes varied among animals (Table 1), the severity of hemorrhagic shock in response to 30% bleeding was apparently variable. The percentage decrease in MAC significantly correlated with the percentage decrease in CO and with the percentage increase in lactate. MAC decreased by <5% in two animals after 30% bleeding (including one pig in which MAC did not change), and these two animals did not show an increase in lactate throughout the study. Therefore, our results indicate that, even under conditions of compensated hemorrhagic shock, alteration of the MAC of isoflurane depends on the severity of the shock. Previous reports have demonstrated that hypotension (MAP decreased more than 50%) induced by several hypotensive drugs (17) or trimethaphan in combination with hemorrhage and a head-up tilt (12) decrease MAC; however, our results indicate that a hemorrhage-induced decrease in MAC is not necessarily accompanied by marked hypotension. Hydroxyethylstarch infusion equivalent to the volume of withdrawn blood increased CO more than observed under baseline conditions, and partially reversed the increase in HR and the decrease in CVP caused by hemorrhagic shock (Table 1). However, fluid resuscitation did not reverse the decrease in MAC. This is consistent with our previous report, in which we showed that a slight increase in the hypnotic effect of isoflurane induced by decompensated hemorrhagic shock (withdrawal of 40% of the blood volume) cannot be reversed by fluid resuscitation (8), although the alteration of the hypnotic effect is minimal. Therefore, at least over a relatively short duration, fluid resuscitation does not reverse the increase in potency of isoflurane for production of hypnosis and immobility. Cullen and Eger (18) have shown that MAC of halothane remains normal in acute isovolemic anemia in dogs, despite reduction of hematocrit to 10%. In their study, isovolemic anemia was induced by stepwise hemorrhage and an equal volume of dextran infusion to keep the decrease in MAP within 10%; CO increased by approximately 53%, but pH and base excess did not change significantly throughout the study. Therefore, fluid infusion before the appearance of tissue hypoxia and acidosis due to hemorrhage might be effective in preventing a decrease in MAC. Administration of naloxone after fluid resuscitation reversed the decrease in MAC, but did not reverse the metabolic changes. Although shock-induced metabolic changes might mediate activation of endogenous opioid pathways, the effect of naloxone suggests that the decrease in MAC during hemorrhagic shock is not directly caused by metabolic changes but by activation of endogenous opioid pathways. In fact several studies have reported that naloxone has no effect on the MAC of inhaled anesthetics under normal conditions (19–22). To our knowledge, this is the first report showing that opioid receptors mediate a portion of the decrease in MAC. Hemorrhagic shock produces immediate activation of the autonomic nervous system and endogenous opioid pathways (23–25). In an isobaric hemorrhagic model in rats, Molina (25) has demonstrated that hemorrhage increases the plasma levels of corticosterone (30%), adrenocorticotrophic hormone (three-fold), β-endorphin (four-fold), and epinephrine and norepinephrine (20–50-fold). Furthermore, in conscious and unrestrained rats, endogenous opioid activation during hemorrhagic shock produces analgesia, as measured using the tail-flick response to a noxious stimulus, and this analgesia is not observed in hemorrhagic shock animals pretreated with naltrexone (a µ-opioid antagonist) (14). These findings are consistent with the results of the present study. In our previous studies, we have demonstrated that 30% bleeding does not alter the EEG effect of isoflurane, but 40% bleeding (decompensated hemorrhagic state) slightly alters this effect, causing an approximately 12% decrease in effect-site concentration that produces 50% of the maximal spectral edge effect (7,8). Taken together with the present findings, it appears that endogenous opioids induced by hemorrhagic shock may contribute to these pharmacodynamic changes. Evaluation of these changes using an EEG suggests a minimal alteration in anesthetic potency; however, evaluation of the pharmacodynamic effect using movement in response to a noxious stimulus suggests a larger effect, because this method is more sensitive to opioid-related events. In fact, MAC and MAC-bar (minimum alveolar concentration to block adrenergic response to surgical incision in 50% patients) are decreased markedly compared to MAC-awake (minimum alveolar concentration to prevent response to a verbal command in 50% of patients) in the presence of opioids, and the mechanisms underlying the decreases in these values are not comparable (26). Although we did not measure the plasma concentration of β-endorphin in the present study, we speculate that this level would differ depending on the severity of hemorrhagic shock, leading to different decreases in MAC. Molina (27) has demonstrated in animals that a marked increase of the plasma β- endorphin level occurs after soft tissue trauma and lipopolysaccharide administration, similarly to the effects of hemorrhage; therefore we speculate that alteration of MAC values might be observed under several different stress conditions. Several limitations of the present study need to be addressed. Although the study was performed using withdrawal of an exact amount of blood, according to our series of previous studies (7,8,16), animals varied in their degree of metabolic compromise or compensation capacity in response to hemorrhagic shock. Hence, use of an isobaric hemorrhage model (4,14) might have been more appropriate to obtain an equivalent degree of metabolic compromise among animals; under these conditions, a clearer and more consistent decrease in MAC might have been observed at the same shock level. In addition, the time-dependence of the observed changes in MAC was not investigated, and it is possible that the duration of the hemorrhagic shock state and/or the period after fluid resuscitation might have influenced MAC. Furthermore, a time-control study of MAC in the absence of hemorrhage was not performed, and it is possible that repetitive noxious stimuli during MAC assessment might have influenced subsequent determinations of MAC. Finally, because naloxone was administered after fluid infusion, the reversal in MAC might not have been solely due to the effect of naloxone. The interpretation of the data would be more reliable if a naloxone group without fluid infusion after 30% bleeding had been included. In summary, hemorrhagic shock decreased the MAC of isoflurane depending on the severity of the shock. Subsequent fluid resuscitation did not reverse the decrease in MAC, but additional administration of a µ-opioid antagonist reversed the change in MAC. Our results suggest that activation of the endogenous opioid system explains the decrease in MAC during hemorrhagic shock, and further indicate that alterations in anesthetic potency in response to hemorrhage differ at anesthetic sites of action for production of hypnosis and immobility.
Accepted for publication July 24, 2007.
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|