| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Thoracic epidural anesthesia (TEA) combined with general anesthesia (GA) as well as total-IV anesthesia (TIVA) are both established anesthetic managements for thoracic surgery. We compared them with respect to hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction, shunt fraction and oxygenation during one-lung ventilation. Fifty patients, ASA physical status II-III undergoing pulmonary resection were randomly allocated to two groups. In the TIVA group, anesthesia was maintained with propofol and fentanyl. In the TEA group, anesthesia was maintained with TEA (bupivacaine 0.5%) combined with low-dose concentration 0.30.5 vol% of isoflurane (end-tidal). Changing from two-lung ventilation to one-lung ventilation caused a significant increase in cardiac output (CO) in the TIVA group, whereas no change was observed in the TEA group. One-lung ventilation caused significant increases in shunt fraction in both groups which was associated per definition with a significant decrease in PaO2 in both groups but PaO2 remained significantly increased in the TEA group (P < 0.05). We conclude that both anesthetic regimens are safe intraoperatively. However, TEA in combination with GA did not impair arterial oxygenation to the same extent as TIVA, which might be a result of the changes in CO. Therefore, patients with preexisting cardiopulmonary disease and impaired oxygenation before one-lung ventilation might benefit from TEA combined with GA.
Implications: Fifty patients underwent lung surgery through the opened chest wall requiring ventilation of only one lung. Patients were randomly assigned to receive either general anesthesia alone or in combination with regional anesthesia via a catheter in the back. Oxygen content in the blood and blood pressure was better maintained in the group receiving the combination of general with regional anesthesia.
Anesthetic regimens used for thoracic surgery include total-IV anesthesia (TIVA), general anesthesia (GA) with volatile anesthetics, and thoracic epidural anesthesia (TEA) combined with GA. They have different effects on hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction (HPV), pulmonary and systemic hemodynamics, and the incidence of hypoxemia during one-lung ventilation (13). TIVA has been compared to GA with inhaled anesthetics in multiple studies with respect to oxygenation and shunt fraction during one-lung ventilation. Although it is generally accepted that volatile anesthetics inhibit HPV and may promote hypoxemia in a dose-dependent manner during one-lung ventilation (1,2), IV anesthetics including propofol inhibit HPV to a minor degree (2,4). With TEA, Garutti et al. (3) observed higher shunt fractions and lower PaO2 values compared with TIVA. In experimental studies, TEA has not influenced HPV and has minimally influenced pulmonary and systemic hemodynamics (58). In addition, a metaanalysis of Ballantyne et al. (9) confirmed that clinical measures of pulmonary outcome (incidence of infections, atelectasis, or other complications) are significantly improved by epidural local anesthetic treatment. However, the preferred regimens, TEA combined with GA and TIVA, have not been compared with respect to their intraoperative clinical relevance (HPV, hemodynamic variables, and hypoxemia). The purpose of the study was to investigate arterial oxygenation and shunt fraction during one-lung ventilation with respect to hemodynamic variables throughout surgery in patients undergoing thoracotomies with pulmonary resections.
Fifty patients, ASA physical status IIIII, scheduled for elective pulmonary surgery, gave their written informed consent to participate in this prospective, controlled, randomized study approved by the local Ethics Committees. All patients required thoracotomies for pulmonary resections in the lateral decubitus position and one-lung ventilation. Preoperative history and examination, as well as laboratory results, elec-trocardiogram, chest radiograph, preoperative pul-monary function tests, and perfusion scans were obtained. Before induction of anesthesia hemodynamic monitoring was established with a radial artery catheter contralateral to the operated side for invasive blood pressure monitoring, arterial blood gas sampling and hemoglobin determinations. A pulmonary artery catheter was inserted in the right jugular vein to the pulmonary capillary wedge position for pulmonary artery pressure (PAP) monitoring, mixed venous blood gas sampling and thermodilution cardiac output measurements. The correct position (pulmonary artery of the dependent lung) of the pulmonary artery catheter was confirmed by preoperative chest radiographs. Heart rate (HR), arterial blood pressure (systolic and diastolic), and PAP (systolic and diastolic) were continuously monitored and recorded (Solar 8000; Marquette Hellige, Freiburg, Germany). Arterial oxygen saturation (SpO2) was continuously monitored by pulse oximetry. Inspired oxygen fraction (FIO2) and end-tidal isoflurane concentration as well as end-tidal CO2 were measured (Solar 8000, Marquette Hellige). Additional monitoring in all patients included esophageal temperature, electrocardiogram, and tidal volume measurements. All patients received 0.51.0 mg flunitrazepam orally 1 h before their arrival in the operating room. Anesthesia was induced in both groups with IV doses of thiopental (35 mg/kg), fentanyl (510 µg/kg), and pancuronium (0.1 mg/kg). For maintenance of anesthesia, the patients were randomized to either the TIVA group or the TEA (TEA combined with GA) group. In the TIVA group anesthesia was maintained with IV propofol at continuous infusion rates of 610 mg · kg-1 · h-1 and IV fentanyl (510 µg/kg boli intermittently until 1 h before end of surgery). In the TEA group, an epidural catheter was placed at the T6-7 or T7-8 interspace using the paramedian approach before induction of anesthesia. The epidural space was identified by the loss of resistance technique using a 10 mL-glass syringe filled with 0.9% saline. After placement of the catheter a test dose of 15 mg bupivacaine 0.5% isobar was given to exclude intrathecal position. Then the initial dose of bupivacaine 0.5% depending on the age and size of the patient (range 1525 mg) was injected via the epidural catheter. In total, 3040 mg bupivacaine 0.5% (test dose plus initial dose) was given before surgical incision. The level of anesthesia was determined by loss of pinprick sensation. For intraoperative use, a dosage interval of 80 min was chosen. The individual dose for every patient was titrated depending on the initial required dose, age and size (range 1525 mg bupivacaine 0.5%). Epinephrine as addition to local anesthetics was not given with respect to possible influences on shunt fraction during one-lung ventilation. Anesthesia was maintained with an end-tidal concentration of 0.30.5 vol % isoflurane. Relaxation was provided with a single dose of IV pancuronium 0.050.15 mg/kg in both groups. Blood temperature was kept constant within 0.5°C and >35.5°C. Vasoactive drugs were not given and would have been considered an exclusion criterion. Volume treatment was controlled in both groups with crystalloids and colloids to keep the patient in stable fluid balance. Central venous pressure and pulmonary wedge pressure were not allowed to differ more than 10% from baseline values. In addition, after change of position the values were compared to previous values and taken as baseline data. If hemoglobin levels decreased below 8 g/dL, erythrocyte transfusions were administered to maintain a hemoglobin level of 10 g/dL. After induction of anesthesia, a left-sided double-lumen tube (Broncho-cath; Mallinckrodt Inc., Argyle, NY) was inserted. The correct position of the tube was determined by auscultation and confirmed by fiberoptic bronchoscopy before and after the patient was in the lateral decubitus position. The patients lungs were ventilated with intermittent positive pressure (Aestiva 3000; Ohmeda GmbH, Erlangen, Germany). Ventilation was controlled with FIO2 1.0 and a tidal volume of 10 mL/kg at a rate to maintain PaCO2 (arterial) within 35 to 40 mm Hg. Continuous positive airway pressure or positive end expiratory pressure ventilation were not applied before finishing step 4 of the experimental sequence. Our experimental protocol consisted of seven steps. During each step, hemodynamic measurements were taken and arterial and mixed venous blood gases obtained.
Each set of hemodynamic measurements, obtained at the end of expiration, consisted of HR, mean arterial pressure (MAP), central venous pressure, mean pulmonary artery pressure, pulmonary capillary wedge pressure, and cardiac output (CO). CO was measured by thermodilution technique and expressed as the mean of three consecutive measurements in one patient at each step ( Systemic vascular resistance (SVR), pulmonary vascular resistance, and arteriovenous oxygen difference (C(a-v)O2) were calculated using standard formulas. The following formulas were used to calculate venous admixture (QsQt):
All data were expressed as median and range. Statistical analysis was performed using the Mann-Whitney U-test for determining intergroup differences. For intragroup analysis, the Friedman test for global significances was used. If there was a significant difference detected by the Friedman test globally, Wilcoxons signed rank sum test for matched pairs was used to analyze the difference locally. Changes in hemodynamic data were analyzed using the Bonferroni correction for multiple comparisons. Spearman correlation coefficients were calculated. A P < 0.05 and the Bonferroni corrected P , respectively, were considered significant.
Fifty patients were studied. Basic patient characteristics did not differ between groups ( Table 1). Before induction (Step 1) of GA significant differences concerning hemodynamic and oxygenation variables were not observed between groups ( Table 2). After induction of anesthesia during two-lung ventilation in the supine and lateral decubitus position (Steps 23) CO decreased significantly in the TIVA group, whereas it remained unchanged in the TEA group ( Fig. 1). MAP decreased significantly in both groups after induction of anesthesia, but no differences between groups were found (Table 2). Changing from two-lung ventilation to one-lung ventilation (Step 4), PaO2 decreased significantly (P < 0.05) in both groups, but PaO2 values remained significantly (P < 0.05) higher in the TEA group compared with the TIVA group (Fig. 1). However, no case of hypoxemia (defined as PaO2 < 75 mm Hg) was observed in either group. Furthermore shunt fraction increased significantly in both groups to the same extent (Fig. 1). Changing from two-lung to one-lung ventilation, CO increased significantly in the TIVA group (Fig. 1). Returning to two-lung ventilation (Steps 56), MAP and SVR remained significantly higher in the TIVA group (Table 2).
After extubation (Step 7) hemodynamic as well as oxygenation variables did not differ significantly between groups except for MAP and SVR (Table 2). Time to extubation was significantly shorter in the TEA group (13 min, range 1030 min) than in the TIVA group (45 min, range 2560 min) in our protocol design. Postoperative pain relief was superior in the TEA group compared with the TIVA group ( Fig. 2). Complications associated with the TEA technique such as bleeding, infections, or postspinal headache were not observed. Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation II scores on admission to ICU did not differ between groups. ICU stay was significantly shorter in the TEA group (median, 2 days; range 18 days) than in the TIVA group (median 3 days; range 116 days) (P < 0.04). Twenty-eight percent of the patients in the TIVA group developed pneumonia during their ICU stay compared with 12 percent of the patients in the TEA group (P < 0.16; Power 29%).
The most important findings of our study were that TEA combined with GA showed improved arterial oxygenation during one-lung ventilation compared with TIVA, that CO was maintained stable in the TEA group throughout surgery compared with the TIVA group, and that time to extubation was significantly shorter in the TEA group in our protocol design. Improved arterial oxygenation in the TEA group was achieved despite equal shunt fractions during one-lung ventilation. Although CO was significantly lower in the TIVA than in the TEA group during two-lung ventilation, it significantly increased after one-lung ventilation. This increase even exceeded the CO values in the TEA group during one-lung ventilation. CO correlated slightly but significantly (one-lung ventilation; r = 0.34; P = 0.02) with the shunt fraction in the TIVA group. An increase in CO is usually associated with an increased shunt fraction while PaO2 is unchanged or decreased (11). Decreases in CO are associated with decreased PAP, which can potentiate HPV and reduce shunt (11). In the presence of regional atelectasis, PaO2 is significantly affected by CO (11). Previous clinical studies have shown controversial results with regard to oxygenation, shunt fraction, and hemodynamic variables during one-lung ventilation (2,4,12,13). Van Keer et al. (4) studied 10 patients requiring thoracotomy. Anesthesia was maintained with continuous IV propofol infusion (10 mg/kg/h). During two-lung ventilation and one-lung ventilation no change in CO, shunt fraction, and PaO2 was observed. This might be a result of methodological differences because one-lung ventilation measurements were started before opening the chest. Kellow et al. (12) investigated patients undergoing thoracotomy and observed a significant increase of cardiac index and shunt fraction changing from two-lung ventilation to one-lung ventilation. However, the interpretation of the shunt fraction is limited because patients were ventilated with 50% nitrous oxide in oxygen and PaO2 was not determined. Steegers et al. (13) studied 14 patients requiring lobectomy and continuous IV propofol infusion (69 mg/kg/h). Shunt fraction and PaO2 did not differ during one-lung ventilation compared to two-lung ventilation. Their study did not include any baseline data such as CO. Changes in these hemodynamic variables would cause secondary changes in the pulmonary circulation (12). Spies et al. (2) compared TIVA with propofol (10 mg/kg/h) versus 1 MAC enflurane in patients undergoing thoracotomy. CO and shunt fraction increased significantly changing from two-lung to one-lung ventilation, whereas PaO2 per definition decreased. This was in accordance with our results. Changing to one-lung ventilation caused significantly higher increases of CO and lower PaO2 values in the TIVA group compared with the TEA group.
TEA has not inhibited HPV in experimental studies (5,6). Ishibe et al. (5) demonstrated an enhanced HPV response and improved arterial oxygenation during one-lung ventilation with TEA in dogs, which resulted from decreased PvO2 and low CO because of sympathetic nerve activity blockade. Brimioulle et al. (6) observed increased HPV during epidural blockade but no effect from previous During thoracic surgery it is important to maintain the competence of HPV. This is preserved if cardiac function is maintained as close as possible to preoperative values (12). Even if MAP and SVR values were lower in the TEA group, hemodynamic stability with regard to CO was better maintained in the TEA group than in the TIVA group. These results have already been reported in preliminary clinical studies (7,8). TEA produces minor reductions in CO, HR, and blood pressure (7). Tanaka et al. (8) measured CO using the suprasternal Doppler method and the thermodilution method with a Swan-Ganz-catheter in 13 patients undergoing thoracotomy with small-dose TEA. Only minor decreases of MAP after endotracheal intubation were observed. Cardiac index and pulmonary wedge pressure were essentially unchanged during the study period. With propofol, Spies et al. (2) observed a significant decrease of MAP and CO after induction of anesthesia in patients undergoing thoracotomy. In addition, Larsen et al. (19) observed significant decreases in cardiac index attributable to a negative inotropic effect of propofol. Extubation after surgery was performed significantly earlier in the TEA group than in the TIVA group in our protocol design. No previous study has compared TEA combined with GA versus TIVA in patients with lung resections with regard to time to extubation. Boldt et al. (20) reported extubation times of 31 ± 10 min in patients after thoracotomy with propofol and fentanyl. This is shorter than what we observed in our patients. However, in our study patients received continuous propofol infusion/inhaled isoflurane in the same dose range until Step 6 measurements were finished to have comparable hemodynamic and oxygen-transport related variables. Because of the fact that larger doses of propofol are required for thoracic surgery (2), the prolonged infusion might have accounted for the prolonged time to extubation in the TIVA group. In addition, Hughes et al. (21) reported an increased context-sensitive half-time of propofol with infusion duration. Therefore, it cannot be eliminated that accumulation might have biased the results with regard to extubation time. In addition, early extubation is clinically relevant because of a decreased incidence of pulmonary infection rates and shortened postoperative stay on the ICU resulting in reduction of costs, in particular after cardiac and thoracoabdominal surgery (22,23) The TEA procedure may also be relevant in postoperative pain control. In our study, postoperative pain relief was superior and ICU stay shorter in the TEA group with epidural bupivacaine compared with the TIVA group with IV piritramide. This has been shown already in previous clinical studies (9,24). A cumulative metaanalysis confirmed that postoperative epidural pain control can significantly decrease the incidence of pulmonary morbidity (9). In conclusion, both anesthetic regimens are safe intraoperatively. TEA combined with GA did not impair arterial oxygenation. However, PaO2 decreased significantly in the TIVA group compared with the TEA group. This might be attributable to the increase in CO in the TIVA group after one-lung ventilation, whereas CO remained stable in the TEA group. Therefore, patients with cardiopulmonary disease might profit from TEA combined with GA with respect to oxygenation and stable hemodynamics during one-lung ventilation.
We thank Dr. U. Mansmann, MD, representive Head of the Department of Statistical Medicine, Free University of Berlin, for his assistance in statistical analysis. We also thank Dr. Michael Martin, MD, of our Department of Anesthesiology and Intensive Care, Charité, for helping to correct the paper as a native speaker.
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|