| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
In this study we sought to determine the acute cerebrovascular effects of intracarotid adenosine by using real-time cerebral blood flow (CBF) measurements in nonhuman primates. The internal carotid arteries of healthy anesthetized baboons were transfemorally cannulated. Changes in CBF were continuously measured at baseline and with 6 increasing doses of adenosine (0.002 to 1.5 mg/min) by use of an intraparenchymal thermal diffusion (TD) probe. Each infusion lasted 5 min. At baseline and at the largest dose of adenosine, CBF was also determined by the intraarterial 133Xe technique. TD measurements revealed a dose-dependent increase in CBF from 32 ± 6 mL · l00 g-1 · min-1 at baseline to 90 ± 38 mL · l00 g-1 · min-1 with the largest dose of adenosine (n = 5; P < 0.0001). A similar magnitude of increase in CBF was also observed with 133Xe CBF measurements. No significant increases in intracranial pressure or adverse systemic hemodynamic side effects were observed during adenosine infusion. The increase in CBF after adenosine lasted only for the duration of drug infusion. In conclusion, the transient cerebrovascular effects of intracarotid adenosine make it suitable for a trial of intraarterial vasodilator therapy and for controlled manipulation of cerebrovascular resistance. IMPLICATIONS: Using a real-time cerebral blood flow (CBF) measurement technique, we evaluated the acute cerebrovascular effects of intracarotid adenosine in anesthetized baboons. The increase in CBF lasted only for the duration of the adenosine infusion. Adenosine might be a suitable drug for trial as an intraarterial vasodilator for the treatment of cerebral vasospasm.
Significant neurological complications have been reported with intraarterial infusion of papaverine for the treatment of cerebral vasospasm (13). The exact etiology of these neurological side effects is unclear. However, some of them have been attributed to an increase in intracranial pressure (ICP) or cerebral steal (4,5). Compared with the elimination half-life of papaverine (107 min), the half-life of adenosine is exceedingly short (110 s) (6,7). Because of its short half-life and potent vasodilator properties, adenosine is an ideal drug for a trial of intraarterial vasodilator therapy before the use of longer-acting vasodilators, such as papaverine. There are limited human data with regard to the cerebrovascular effects of intracarotid adenosine (Table 1) (11). Therefore, there is a clinical need to investigate the cerebrovascular effect of intracarotid adenosine.
The effects of intracarotid adenosine on ICP and the duration of its cerebrovascular effects have not been reported. The effects of intracarotid adenosine vary considerably across experimental models (Table 2), although most nonhuman primate studies show a robust increase in cerebral blood flow (CBF) (13,14,20,21). The aim of our study was to investigate the effect of intracarotid adenosine on the cerebrovascular variables of healthy baboons. We measured CBF by an intraparenchymal thermal diffusion (TD) probe that measures tissue perfusion in real time. We hypothesized that, because of its exceedingly short half-life, intracarotid adenosine would have transient cerebrovascular effects. Furthermore, we hypothesized that, because of rapid metabolism of the drug during transit through the brain, the increase in CBF with intracarotid adenosine would not be associated with systemic side effects.
After approval by the institutions animal care and use committee, the studies were undertaken on adult male baboons (Papio anubis). The anatomical organization of cerebral circulation of these nonhuman primates is fairly similar to that of humans (22,23). The animals were sedated with IM ketamine (20 mg/kg). After IV access was obtained, the animals were intubated and mechanically ventilated. Anesthesia was maintained with an end-tidal isoflurane (ETiso) concentration of 1%1.5%. A femoral arterial line was placed to continuously monitor the systemic blood pressure. A nasopharyngeal probe was used to monitor temperature. The nasopharyngeal temperature was kept constant between 35.0°C and 36.0°C by using a Bair Hugger® (Augustine Medical Inc., Eden Prairie, MN) (24). The animals were subsequently placed prone on a stereotactic frame. Under sterile surgical conditions, 2 5-mm frontal burr holes were drilled approximately 1.5 cm lateral to the midline. The dura was carefully penetrated with a spinal needle and irrigated to ensure that there was no bleeding. Two bolts were inserted into the skull. Through one bolt, an intraparenchymal TD probe (Q flow-400®; Thermal Technologies Inc., Cambridge, MA) was advanced approximately 1 cm beyond the dura, so as to be embedded deep within the gray matter. Through another bolt, a fiberoptic ICP probe (Camino®; Integra Life Sciences Corp., Plainsboro, NJ) was advanced to approximately the same distance (Fig. 1).
The Q flow-400 TD probe can quantify tissue perfusion (mL · l00 g-1 · min-1) in a small volume of tissue (30100 µL) in real time. The flexible probe is 2 mm in diameter. The advantage of this TD technique is that it quantifies perfusion without the need for a no-flow calibration. It does so by determining the conductive properties of the tissue from the initial rate of propagation of the thermal field when the heat to the probe is first turned on, and it uses the measure of conduction to determine the thermal convection (blood flow) component of the heat transfer. The performance of the Q flow-400 probe has been validated in experimental and clinical settings (25,26). Once both the Q flow-400 and ICP devices were functioning optimally, as judged by the stability of the reading and the quality of the wave forms, the animals were turned supine. The skin over the contralateral femoral artery was infiltrated with 0.5% bupivacaine. A 4.5F introducer sheath (Check-Flo®; Cook Co. Inc., Bloomington, IN) was placed in the femoral artery. Through the introducer sheath, a 4F coaxial catheter (Cook Co. Inc., Bloomington, IN) was advanced into the common carotid artery. A microcatheter (1.8F, Fastracker-10®; Target Therapeutics, Boston Scientific International, Cedex, France) was then guided, via the coaxial sheath, into the internal carotid artery (ICA). Satisfactory positioning of the ICA catheter was angiographically verified. We used the following criteria for satisfactory placement of the microcatheter in the ICA to eliminate vasospasm: 1) there was free flow of angiographic contrast after intraarterial injections; 2) a pressure wave could be recorded through the microcatheter; and 3) the pressure recorded in the ICA (Pica) was within 10% of the mean arterial blood pressure (MAP) recorded in the femoral artery. To minimize the risks of thromboembolism, heparin (1000 U) was administered IV after placement of endovascular catheters. Besides the TD measurements, at baseline and at the largest dose of adenosine, CBF was also determined by the intraarterial 133Xe injection technique. The technique involved a bolus injection of 0.81 mCi of 133Xe dissolved in 1 mL of saline that was rapidly flushed with a 3- to 4-mL bolus of normal saline. This resulted in an instantaneous input function, thus avoiding the need to determine arterial concentration for deconvolution analysis of the washout curve (27). The washout of the tracer was recorded over the middle cerebral artery distribution by a collimated cadmium telluride scintillation detector (Carolina Medical Inc., King, NC), in proximity of the TD and ICP probes as confirmed by angiography (Fig. 2). Blood flow was determined by analyzing the slope of the 133Xe washout curve (initial slope index) from 20 to 80 s after tracer injection. This method yields a value of CBF that is biased toward the gray matter (28). Given a blood-brain partition coefficient of 1 for the gray matter, initial slope index can be expressed in milliliters per 100 g per minute (29). Bolus injection of 133Xe was delivered approximately 3.5 min after an intracarotid infusion was started. The intracarotid infusions were resumed immediately after 133Xe injection. Tracer washout was recorded for 90 s. Hemodynamic variables, such as heart rate and MAP, were recorded at the end of tracer washout. A sample of arterial blood was obtained for each 133Xe CBF measurement for determination of the PaCO2 (mm Hg) and hematocrit (Hct; %). Cerebrovascular resistance (CVR; mm Hg · mL-1 · 100 g-1 · min-1) was calculated by dividing the Pica by CBF.
A preliminary study was conducted on one adult baboon. These data were not included in the final dose-response analysis. During this experiment, we tested only one dose of adenosine (1 mg/min). This dose was based on our previous experience with adenosine (21). In this animal, the hemodynamic variables were not affected by intracarotid adenosine, but CBF, measured both by TD and the 133Xe technique, nearly doubled. Other investigators had reported a significant increase in baboons with 0.3 and 0.5 mg/min (13,14). We therefore elected, for the final dose-response studies, to test 3 smaller (0.002, 0.02, and 0.2 mg/min) and 3 larger (0.5, 1.0, and 1.5 mg/min) doses of intracarotid adenosine. All drugs were freshly prepared in normal saline, and the infusion rate was kept constant at 1 mL/min. On the basis of a molecular weight of 267.24, these doses corresponded to molar concentrations of 0.007, 0.07, 10.7, 2, 4, and 6 mM, respectively. Although the effect of adenosine appeared to be transient, we were not certain at the start of the study that all cerebrovascular effects of intracarotid adenosine would be immediately reversed on cessation of infusion. Thus, to minimize the time required for all seven measurements, we escalated the doses of the drug, rather than administering the doses in a random manner. It was also noted during the preliminary study that bolus injection of 133Xe resulted in an increase in the TD values. Whether this was due to bolus drug delivery or an interference with thermal equilibrium after 133Xe injection can only be speculated. Thus, in the subsequent studies, TD values were averaged for 30 s before 133Xe injection. The experimental protocol involved seven sequential CBF measurements. The first CBF value was determined during intracarotid infusion of normal saline (baseline). Subsequently, six doses of adenosine were infused into the ICA. Each intracarotid infusion lasted for approximately 5 min. To minimize the time for the study, we used progressively increasing doses of the drug. All measurements were completed within 3545 min to avoid the time-dependent effects of prolonged isoflurane anesthesia on the CBF of primates (30). At the end of the experiment, the location of the catheter and the integrity of the cerebral arteries were confirmed by angiography. The animals were killed with a pentobarbital/potassium chloride mixture. At autopsy, the brain was inspected for any injury at the site of probe placement. All data are presented as mean ± SD and were analyzed by repeated-measures analysis of variance. Post hoc testing was performed by using Tukeys procedure. Simple regression analysis was used to compare the correlation between the results obtained by TD and 133Xe CBF measurements. Saline and adenosine were used as the grouping variable.
The study was conducted on five adult male baboons weighing 14 ± 4 kg. In all animals, the ICA catheters were placed satisfactorily, and there was no evidence of vasospasm during angiography. Data from the preliminary study were excluded from dose-response and correlation analysis. A preliminary study was conducted on one animal weighing 10.5 kg, in whom CBF measurements were performed at baseline and after intracarotid adenosine (1 mg/min). The TD measurements in this animal showed an increase in CBF from 76 to 136 mL · l00 g-1 · min-1 after adenosine. The corresponding increase in CBF by 133Xe measurements was from 62 to 111 mL · l00 g-1 · min-1. MAP increased from 66 to 74 mm Hg, and heart rate increased from 117 to 120 bpm. The ICP increased from 15 to 18 mm Hg. PaCO2 did not change during adenosine infusion.
Temperature, Hct, PaCO2, and ETiso concentrations did not change during the study (Table 3). TD measurements revealed a dose-dependent increase in CBF after intracarotid infusion of adenosine at doses >0.2 mg/min. The increase in CBF was exceedingly transient and lasted for only the duration of drug infusion (Fig. 2). At the smaller doses (<0.2 mg/min), adenosine did not increase CBF. At the largest dose of 1.5 mg/min, CBF increased from the baseline value of 32 ± 6 mL · l00 g-1 · min-1 to 90 ± 38 mL · l00 g-1 · min-1 (n = 5; P < 0.001). TD measurements also revealed that the increase in blood flow after intracarotid adenosine was promptly reversed on cessation of infusion. Corresponding to the changes in TD was an increase in CBF, evident by 133Xe CBF measurements, from 28 ± 9 mL · l00 g-1 · min-1 to 76 ± 34 mL · l00 g-1 · min-1 (n = 5; P < 0.03) at the largest dose. The MAP, Pica, and cerebral perfusion pressure (CPP) did not change significantly during intracarotid adenosine infusion. Three animals showed no change in ICP during adenosine infusions. In the remaining two animals, ICP increased from 7 to 16 mm Hg and from 19 to 30 mm Hg. The increase in ICP (13 ± 5 mm Hg to 17 ± 7 mm Hg; P = 0.8; n = 5; Table 3) and the decrease in CPP (61 ± 13 mm Hg to 54 ± 16 mm Hg; P = 0.9; n = 5) with intracranial adenosine were not statistically significant. Furthermore, with the largest dose of adenosine (1.5 mg/min), there was no correlation between the percentage increase in ICP from baseline and the percentage increase in TD CBF: %
Collectively, there was some correlation between all 10 CBF measurements (baseline and adenosine) with both the TD and intraarterial 133Xe techniques: TD = 27 + 0.7 133Xe (r2 = 0.318; n = 10; P = 0.08) (Fig. 3). However, only the baseline CBF values showed a statistically significant correlation: TD (baseline) = 14 + 0.63 133Xe (r2 = 0.976; n = 5; P = 0.001). There was no correlation between the CBF values obtained by the TD and 133Xe CBF methods after intracarotid infusion of adenosine: TD (adenosine) = 92 - 0.03 133Xe (r2 = 0.001; n = 5; P = 0.96).
Autopsy revealed normal brains that showed no gross injury or bleeding along the track of the ICP or the TD probe.
There were three significant results of this study. First, two independent flow-measurement techniques demonstrated a robust increase in CBF after intracarotid adenosine in nonhuman primates. A clear dose-dependent increase in CBF and a decrease in CVR were evident by TD measurements. Second, intracarotid adenosine did not result in a significant increase in ICP. Thus, CPP was maintained during intracarotid adenosine infusion. Third, the cerebrovascular effects of intracarotid adenosine were exceedingly transient, and the blood flow promptly returned to near-baseline values immediately after cessation of infusion. Collectively, these results suggest that in nonhuman primates, intracarotid adenosine (0.51.5 mg/min) significantly decreases CVR. The decrease in CVR is transient and is not associated with systemic side effects. Most previous studies demonstrating the effect of adenosine on CBF used the 133Xe-injection technique. 133Xe CBF measurement averages CBF over several minutes. Therefore, 133Xe measurements do not reflect the onset and offset of a drug such as adenosine. In contrast, TD measurements quantify tissue perfusion in real time. TD measurements provide an ideal tool for measuring the response to multiple doses of drugs or for investigating the speed of onset and offset of drug effects, such as with intracarotid adenosine. In human subjects, for example, we had observed a very robust (>150%), although exceedingly transient (<25 seconds), increase in CBF after intraarterial adenosine that was not evidenced by the conventional analysis of the 133Xe washout curve (11). In previous studies with intracarotid adenosine, we had measured CBF by monocompartmental analysis by determining the initial slope of 133Xe washout (20,21). Although such CBF measurements have been validated (29), the monocompartmental analysis primarily reflects flow changes in the gray matter. Differences in vasodilator response to adenosine in different regions of the brain have been observed in small animals (17) and in human subjects (8). Thus, on the basis of intraarterial 133Xe CBF measurements, the possibility that adenosine was selectively affecting a specific anatomical site, such as the caudate nucleus, could not be excluded. Therefore, in this study, as shown in Figures 1 and 2, we positioned the TD deep within the gray matterthe region of the brain that is most likely to benefit from the increase in blood flow and the neuroprotective properties of adenosine. During this study, we observed that the baseline CBF values obtained by the intraarterial 133Xe and TD techniques correlated well with each other: TD (baseline) = 14 + 0.63 133Xe (r2 = 0.976; n = 5; P = 0.001). Further, collectively for all animals, CBF measurements by the two techniques revealed a nearly identical increase in flow after intracarotid adenosine (Table 3). However, individually there was no correlation between the 133Xe CBF and TD values obtained after adenosine infusion: TD (adenosine) = 92 - 0.03 133Xe (r2 = 0.001; n = 5; P = 0.9). This could, in part, be explained by our inability to aspirate the microcatheter before 133Xe injection, which probably resulted in a bolus (approximately 0.5 mL) of the drug. The dramatic changes in CBF due to adenosine, as shown in Figure 3, might have interfered with 133Xe CBF mea-surements and could explain the lack of correlation between the CBF values obtained by the two methods after intracarotid adenosine infusion in individual animals.
The second significant finding of this study was that ICP did not increase after intracarotid adenosine. Intraarterial vasodilators, such as nitroprusside and papaverine, are known to significantly increase ICP. In case of nitroprusside, large doses of the drug can double ICP without affecting the CBF of healthy monkeys (31). Few investigators have studied the effects of intraarterial papaverine on both ICP and CBF simultaneously in primates without cerebral vasospasm. Data from patients with cerebral vasospasm suggest that intraarterial papaverine can increase ICP by 100% (4). In the same population, the increase in CBF after intraarterial papaverine is relatively modest ( The lack of an increase in ICP observed in this study, however, should not be an argument against ICP monitoring during intraarterial infusion of adenosine. A strong argument can be made against the small sample size of our study. Furthermore, from a clinical standpoint, any drug that profoundly increases CBF also carries the risk of increasing ICP because of a concomitant increase in intracranial blood volume. The risks might be further increased if the cerebral venous return were obstructed, for example, if the patients head were malpositioned (32). During our experiments, the necks of the animals had to be maximally flexed in the midline to facilitate angiography and to provide ready access to the implanted probes. The effect of the neck flexion on ICP mea-surements during our study can only be speculated, but it could explain the increase in ICP of two animals and the absence of any change in the other three.
The third significant finding of this study was the prompt return of CBF to near-baseline values on cessation of drug infusion. As is evident from Figure 3, adenosine in modest doses ( We therefore conclude that, in nonhuman primates, intraarterial infusion of adenosine in doses of 0.51.5 mg/min results in a profound increase in CBF without significant systemic hemodynamic side effects. Projected to humans on the basis of body weight, intracarotid adenosine (2.57.5 mg/min) might be useful in augmenting CBF. Adenosine could be useful during intraarterial treatment of ischemic stroke and for a trail of intraarterial vasodilator therapy for patients with cerebral vasospasm.
Supported in part by a Foundation for Anesthesia Education and Research/Datex-Ohmeda Basic Science Starter Grant, National Institutes of Health Grant K08 00698, and an Infrastructure Support grant from the Office of Clinical Trials at Presbyterian Hospital (SJ); 133Xe cerebral blood flow equipment was provided by a previous National Institutes of Health grant (RO1 NS 27713). We thank the following staff members of the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Columbia University: Sulli J. Popilskis, DMV, and Bohdan Spiegowski, Institute of Comparative Medicine; and Ludmila L. Karameros, Department of Anesthesiology, for her help in preparing the manuscript. The Q-Flow TD measurement equipment was loaned from Thermal Technologies Inc. (Cambridge, MA).
Presented in part at the annual meeting of the American Society of Anesthesiologists, Orlando, FL, October, 2002.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|